Close

Communications.Management.Marketing

Truth Is Just Perception

Communication Begins Before The Decision

An organization is already communicating through the decisions it makes. Its Communications function might as well have a seat at the table.

Bringing Communications into the process only after a decision has been made rests on the assumption that, should the decision create reputational problems or undermine employee engagement, finding the right words will be enough to resolve them. This amounts to treating an organization’s decisions as inherently sound and assuming that any difficulties they generate are merely a matter of messaging.

In reality, communication must begin before the decision, so that its potential consequences – positive and negative – for stakeholder perceptions can be anticipated and factored into the decision-making process. Reputational or employee engagement risks will not always outweigh a strategic or operational opportunity, but they must inform both how a decision is made and how its implementation is planned.

In this regard, I use the term reputational contamination to describe how an event or action in one area can affect perceptions of an organization in others. This phenomenon stems from two forms of permeability.

The first concerns issues. Social media have already broken down many of the barriers that once separated different areas of public discourse. Generative search engines will accelerate this trend by bringing together information about different facets of an organization in a single answer. As a result, economic, social, political, and ethical considerations will increasingly overlap in stakeholders’ experiences of a brand.

Yet a decision can be perfectly consistent with one function’s objectives while undermining the organization as a whole. A supplier selection may be judged in light of that supplier’s working conditions, while an unfulfilled commercial promise may cause employees to question their leadership’s credibility. Conversely, honoring a commitment to employees despite its cost may strengthen public authorities’ confidence in the organization’s word.

This blurring of boundaries between issues is far from inconsequential: 88% of consumers say that trust in a brand is important or essential to their purchasing decisions. This puts trust on par with value for money (88%) and product quality (89%). Trust, in other words, is one of the major drivers of purchasing decisions.

Image created with ChatGPT – (CC) Christophe Lachnitt

The second form of permeability concerns audiences. A single individual may play several roles over the course of a day – employee, customer, shareholder, activist, and so on – and express views from each of these perspectives on social media. Their expectations may vary depending on the role they are playing, but what they learn in one capacity can reshape their judgment in another.

Research by Danah Boyd and Alice Marwick on Twitter explored the phenomenon of “context collapse”: A tweet reaches audiences that would normally remain separate, each interpreting it through different frames of reference and expectations. The same message can therefore take on different meanings without a single word changing. The Janus-faced communication that those of us who have been in the profession long enough practiced before the digital revolution can no longer rely on audiences remaining insulated from one another. This is another reason why a decision can never be assessed solely within the boundaries of the function that initiated it.

This does not mean that communication cannot be tailored, in both substance and style, to specific audiences. Such tailoring must, however, account for all the stakeholders who may be exposed to it, directly or indirectly. An argument designed for a particular audience, or a different tone in an announcement, may resonate with one group while alienating another. What must ultimately guide every communication is the meaning it conveys about the brand. The same principle applies to stakeholder listening: Analyzing audiences separately must not obscure the messages that travel between them.

These two forms of permeability make it essential for Communications to help shape decisions rather than merely package them for public consumption. When every decision can become a message, and the boundaries between issues and audiences are increasingly porous, employee engagement and corporate reputation must be integral considerations in strategic and operational decision-making. This is, in particular, one of the strongest arguments for giving the Chief Communications Officer a seat on the organization’s executive leadership team.

Ultimately, communication becomes more strategic when it helps improve the very decisions it will later have to explain.

Superception is a media outlet focused on perception issues across communication, management, and marketing in the age of artificial intelligence. It features a blog, a newsletter, and a podcast. It was founded and is published by Christophe Lachnitt.

www.superception.fr

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.